Competency and Autonomy of Children and Adolescents in Pediatric Oncology decision making processes. Comparative research study between Switzerland and Romania
Third-party funded project
Project title Competency and Autonomy of Children and Adolescents in Pediatric Oncology decision making processes. Comparative research study between Switzerland and Romania
Principal Investigator(s) Elger, Bernice Simone
Co-Investigator(s) Wangmo, Tenzin
Badarau, Domnita
Project Members Badarau, Domnita
Organisation / Research unit Ethik / Bio- und Medizinethik (Elger)
Project Website http://ibmb.unibas.ch/research/
Project start 01.01.2012
Probable end 31.12.2015
Status Completed
Abstract

Research topic and study objective :

Given existing research results published so far surounding decisions making in pediatric oncology, the study will investigate parents’ and health care providers’ attitudes and motives concerning minor’s autonomy and inclusion in pediatric oncology decision making, as well as if and how they differ across countries. By using a mixed methods approach, the project aims to examine and compare the reality of a minor’s autonomy in Romania and Switzerland. It is relevant to understand how and whether minors are included in medical decisions, as they may already be aware of their condition and probable prognosis and wish to be involved, especially in end-of-life situations. Being the ones experiencing the symptoms of the disease may make them feel entitled to this knowledge. Therefore, comparable data from Switzerland and Romania can only contribute more to fully understanding and learning about attitudes, motives and barriers concerning ethical decision making in pediatric oncology centres in Switzerland and Romania.

State of research:

For decades end-of-life decision-making has been spurring controversies worldwide, bringing to focus ethical issues and lack of consensus among actors involved in these decisions. Decision making towards the end-of-life is often difficult , dominated by uncertainties around medical treatment, illness’ progression, the capacity of the patient to exert or continue to make autonomous decisions and not least, the complexity of judgments in acknowledging the patient’s transition to an end-of-life state. Such decisions are influenced by many factors: age, capacity to consent, disease, and how, when and by whom should the decision be made. This might differ among countries, due to cultural differences, socio-economic aspects, and it is particularly difficult to assess when it comes to children and adolescents.

It is clear that end-of-life decision making for minors is fraught with uncertainties. Studies concerning inclusion of children in decision making about cancer research and end-of-life preferences, to name a few, have mostly been carried out in either Europe (the Netherlands, Belgium) or in the United States, with most being conducted in the US. Cultural sensitivity varies when it comes to paternalism and attitudes toward end-of-life issues among and between countries and cultural groups. To the best of researcher’s knowledge, research exploring minors’ autonomy and end-of-life decision making has not been done in Switzerland and Romania.  Within Europe, few studies have been carried out on this issue and so far it can be appreciated that none explored differences among countries on this issues.

Study significance :

Study results are expected to provide longitudinal insight into decision making (look at processes from diagnosis to end-of-life) for minor patients living with cancer and to investigate the possiblity of including these minors in end-of-life decision-making processes. By employing mixed methods: quantitative (surveys) and qualitative (interviews) the study will help gain novel and important quantitative data on the inclusion of children in end-of-life decisions and factors influencing these choices and the decision-making processes. The qualitative data will highlight reasons for including/NOT including minors in end-of-life decision making from 2 perspectives: oncologists and patients' parents. Due to the unique diversity within the study sample: recruitment from two culturally distinct countries: Romania and Switzerland and given the potential significant differences between the German, French and Italian speaking parts of Switzerland, the study results are expected to reveal the influences of guidelines, local factors and traditions on paediatric oncology end-of-life decisions. This will add to the existing literature, providing a double perspective regarding actual decisions in pediatric oncology.

Financed by Foundations and Associations

Published results ()

  ID Autor(en) Titel ISSN / ISBN Erschienen in Art der Publikation
Details 1542004  Bădărău, Domniţa Oana  Conflict of interest in international public health research : Case study: Trovafloxacin study in Kano, Nigeria  2224-9680    Publication: Discussion paper / Internet publication 
Details 2362370  Ruhe Katharina M; Badarau, Domnita O; Elger, Bernice S; Wangmo, Tenzin  End-of-life decision making in pediatrics: literature review on children's and adolescents' participation  2329-4515  AJOB empirical bioethics  Publication: JournalArticle (Originalarbeit in einer wissenschaftlichen Zeitschrift) 
Details 2745760  Badarau, Domnita O.; Nast, Rebecca L.; Shaw, David M.  The vulnerability of the individual benefit argument  1526-5161  The American journal of bioethics  JournalItem (Kommentare, Editorials, Rezensionen, Urteilsanmerk., etc. in einer wissensch. Zeitschr. 
Details 2779938  Ruhe, Katharina M.; Wangmo, Tenzin; Badarau, Domnita O.; Elger, Bernice S.; Niggli, Felix  Decision-making capacity of children and adolescents : suggestions for advancing the concept's implementation in pediatric healthcare  1432-1076  European journal of pediatrics  Publication: JournalArticle (Originalarbeit in einer wissenschaftlichen Zeitschrift) 
Details 3669344  Wangmo, Tenzin; Ruhe, Katharina M.; Badarau, Domnita O.; Kühne, Thomas; Niggli, Felix; Elger, Bernice S.; Swiss Paediatric Oncology Group,  Parents' and patients' experiences with paediatric oncology care in Switzerland--satisfaction and some hurdles  1424-7860 ; 1424-3997  Swiss medical weekly  Publication: JournalArticle (Originalarbeit in einer wissenschaftlichen Zeitschrift) 

Cooperations ()

  ID Kreditinhaber Kooperationspartner Institution Laufzeit - von Laufzeit - bis
Details 1016834  Elger, Bernice Simone  Kühne, Thomas, Prof. Dr. med., Co-Referee  Onkologie/Hämatologie, Universitäts-Kinderpital beider Basel  01.06.2011  31.12.2014 
Details 1544173  Elger, Bernice Simone  Dragomir, Monica, Associate Professor  “Prof. Dr. Al. Trestioreanu” Oncology Institute, "Carol Davila" University of Medicine and Pharmacy, Bucharest.  01.10.2012  30.12.2014 
Details 1544174  Elger, Bernice Simone  Colita, Anca, MD  Fundeni Clinic Institute "Carol Davila" University of Medicine and Pharmacy, Bucharest  01.10.2012  30.12.2014 
   

MCSS v5.8 PRO. 0.440 sec, queries - 0.000 sec ©Universität Basel  |  Impressum   |    
16/04/2021